
I’m probably not the first to think that the first Cars was the weak link in the rather strong chain of films that is Pixar (not that it was bad, but it wasn’t as up to their standards). One thing in particular problem I noticed was the lack of human element, which can be found in all Pixar films except in Cars. Now we have Cars 2, the “rev-ed up sequel,” with Lightning McQueen (Owen Wilson), and Mater (Larry the Cable Guy), going on another adventure together.
The story actually shifts to that of Mater instead of McQueen. We see McQueen enter the World Grand Prix against the boastful Francesco Bernoulli (a rather over the top John Turturro). After problems with the first race, their friendship is hurt, and Mater leaves feeling ashamed. On his way out, he gets caught up in espionage, of sorts, with Fin McMissile (the always delightful Michael Caine), and Holley Shiftwell (a rather sincere Emily Mortimer). They are trying to figure out the reason for the sabotaging of a new type of bio-fuel called Allinol (a somewhat clever play on words). We learn that a legion of old cars, called “Lemons” (this is never given much of a back story, but I’m not much of a gear-head). Will Mater be able to save the day and his friendship with McQueen, can the latter win it all?
Pixar has had a solid record with rather excellent films, as had been the case with Up and Toy Story 3 beforehand. Sadly, the streak ends there as Cars 2 doesn’t really improve on the original, rather gets stuck in neutral really. Pixar has a knack for creating a story for all ages, but this one felt more like it was aimed at children. I found Mater to actually get annoying at times and I don’t think team Pixar was ever able to get him off the ground in this story. Granted, he had his evolution throughout the film, but it just didn’t work for me, and it left me disappointed.
The story is the real problem here. The visuals are dazzling as always with Pixar, but the story was a real clunker, which, if you know my preferences, is rather important. It didn’t have the sentimental feeling we often got in a Pixar film, as shown brilliantly in the past two films I noted above. It never truly felt anything more than children entertainment, which isn’t bad, but I expect more from a Pixar film. The ending didn’t really help it either, honestly. I felt it was rather obvious and kind of shoehorned in parts, some of which I never really bought or found all that convincing. And with such talented voice work from Caine and the hilarious Eddie Izzard, and wonderful cameos from the legendary actress’ Sophia Loren and Vanessa Redgrave, they are let down by a script that, maybe with a few more fine tunes, could have been so much better.
Now, am I saying this is the worst film of the year: not at all. Am I being a little harsh constantly comparing it to Pixar’s films? The past two Pixar films were films that really hit emotionally me as far as films go, so to top them would be difficult. The problem was, Cars 2 didn’t even feel like Pixar was trying to top them, and if they were then they are way, way off. I think Pixar can be forgiven for this, as this is the first, and hopefully last, hiccup they have in crafting wonderful films.
Jack’s Grade: C+